Wee Scoops

Measure for Measure

Just Gaunae (vote) No #indyref #scotdecides #scotland2014

The referendum question is wrong.

Mr Salmond has started using and reusing a phrase that is giving me philosophical angst. It is “the sovereign will of the people of Scotland”. He said:

“The reason we are keeping the pound in a currency union, and the reason we are so unambiguous about it, is because we are appealing to the greatest authority of all, that is the sovereign will of the people of Scotland”

The greatest authority of all? Hmmm….

I’ll try to keep my theism out of it – for me the greatest authority of all, eh, isn’t the sovereign will of the Scottish people – but I will allow the First Minister a bye on that one, given the context.

But even in the context of a post-yes-vote negotiation, why would the Scottish voice in that discussion be the greatest authority of all? What about the Welsh? The Northern Irish? The English?

But that isn’t really my main problem with Mr Salmond’s use of the phrase.

I suspect (I may be wrong) that the “sovereign will of the Scottish people” will be no clearer after the referendum  – as the actual will of the Scottish people doesn’t appear on the ballot paper.

I suspect that the Scottish people really want DevoMax.

I suspect that, because of the respectful dialogue phase, that the English too, perhaps less strongly, want their own DevoMax.

I suspect that Alex Salmond really wants DevoMax. I think he thinks he wants independence. I think he really wants DevoMax.

If not, why the currency union as Plan A? – He wants independence, except for the currency. Which isn’t actual independence; it is as Max as a DevoMax could be. What’s best for Scotland is a fiscal union. Apparently.

It seems nuts to jeopardise the fiscal union we already have.

If we really actually want DevoMax, rather than being cast adrift in a sea of transition, I hope people will vote no in the referendum, and then start work towards it.

I can feel the Nationalists bristle and begin to form phrases in their minds about the evils of the untrustworthy Westminster – and yes – Westminster is a problem – not just for Scotland – but moreso for England.

I long for the day when I can watch the news without having to hear about Health and Education in “EnglandandWales”. These matters should be devolved.
But the things that relate to the islands – why not stay banded together for the stuff that is to do with these islands as islands – the stuff that is global?

I think the quality of real debate (not the televised unedifying and embarrassing political squabbling) in the country has been great. I think the “sovereign will” has become clearer on both sides – people have a vision for Scotland –  of enterprise and hard work, of equality and care for the most vulnerable –  and I think it is healthy that we have had a long time to reflect as a nation about the values we share and the potential that this country has.

I hope people vote no, so we can avoid uncertainty and upheaval, but take what we have learnt and start shaping the future –  one policy at a time.

I am thankful that every vote will count in this particular referendum – I am just frustrated that the third option, that I suspect is closest to the “will” of the people of Scotland, is missing.

Advertisements

Single Post Navigation

11 thoughts on “Just Gaunae (vote) No #indyref #scotdecides #scotland2014

  1. What you are proposing is a United States of Britain. Not a bad idea, actually. Except that I don’t want to live in a republic 🙂

    I must say, you’re not one of those vacuous women the No vote people used in their advert. I think it was the No vote people. Whoever it was, they shot themselves in the foot.

    Whatever the result, I hope every Scot thinks as long and as hard as you are doing.

  2. As an insider on the outside looking in I worry, worry, worry.

  3. John Yates on said:

    The sovereign will of the Scottish people is to have our cake and eat it. Ergo, we want rid of the right-wing bammers who govern us and we want to keep everything that is good about being in the Union. That includes, but is not limited to, the pound in all of its economic and sentimental glory.

  4. FYI
    The original plan was for Devomax this year with a vote on full independance in five years. However, politicians always get ahead of themselves.
    We have what we have. My YES vote was posted Friday.
    You do not have to worry though because the result was a foregone conclusion.
    NO it will be.
    As you people of faith would say “God help us all.”

    • You voted? You surprise me Miguel, not least because you are now Farquar. Ironic, though, that you won’t get what you vote for in a vote held to ensure you get what you voted for… But that’s what you always said- if you were going to get what you wanted, they wouldn’t let us vote…

  5. My bad. I Will explain.
    I never vote for a politician. I have voted twice. Both times in referendums.
    I agree with you on Devomax. David Cameron, a politician, was adamant it would not be on the ballot paper. Typical.
    Miguel was for Spain. Now I`m in Alba I liked the sound of Farquar Urquart.
    Stay strong. Love to all.

  6. I think that you made a wise decision 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: