Wee Scoops

Measure for Measure

Back on familiar territory, but is it the Promised Land? #E100

Jesus is considered by scholars such as Weber ...

Jesus is considered by scholars such as Weber to be an example of a charismatic religious leader. (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

In the E100 we are well into the New Testament now. It is as if it has gone from black and white into colour. Everything seems more three dimensional and familiar and every story so far is very well known.

The last swathe of the E100 in the Old Testament was to do with the exile in Babylon. I felt that there was a whole chunk missing, when Ezra and Nehemiah bring the people back and bring back temple worship.

The Old Testament seems to be a cycle of hope and failure. It seems that God tells the people what to do, and then they plan to, but don’t. Then they find themselves far from God and then they decide to have another go at living God’s way and then forget that that was the plan. And so on.

In the New Testament it was interesting to read “The Sermon on the Mount” with the Old Testament as a backdrop. It was as if the people had got it wrong on two fronts. In one way, they had taken the Law too far. On the other, they hadn’t taken it far enough.

In the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus revisits the themes contained in the Ten Commandments and then takes the spirit of the command to its full extent. So, although the “Law” was not to kill, Jesus stretches that to mean that one should not hate/be in conflict. The Law required justice to be done, but Jesus took it further and demanded mercy to be one’s instinctive response.

So, I liked to see that parallel between the Old and the New. There was the feeling that the people had missed the point of the Law. They had started to obsess over it, rather than catching the vision of human life, worship and social interaction that was within the Law.

There is a problem with the Sermon on the Mount, though. Jesus says:

“Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect.”

Now that’s a toughie. This was said in the context of loving one another – even one’s enemies.

What are people meant to do with a command to “Be perfect”? Do we think, “Fine, no problem: ta-dah!” and become perfect? I think that if you are told to be perfect, perhaps a more likely response it to think, “Well, that can’t happen.” It certainly provokes a small voice of humility within, if nothing else.

There is an interesting Old-New bit in Matthew 3 when John the Baptist is preaching. He is speaking to the teachers of the Law:

And do not think you can say to yourselves, ‘We have Abraham as our father.’ I tell you that out of these stones God can raise up children for Abraham.

It seems that from John the Baptist’s preaching, the direct descendancy from Abraham is not enough to be in line for the inheritances and fulfilled promises that God made to Abraham.  It seems that the faithlessness of the people  – the missing the point of the Law – has invalidated their claim. John the Baptist is being controversial here by suggesting that the inheritors could be the stones – presumably meaning that the inheritors could be anyone from anywhere – assuming that they “got” the idea – the idea that Jesus then elaborated on during the Sermon on the Mount and through other acts and utterances.

So I am interested to see how it works out in the rest of the life of Jesus part of the bible. I am not sure, but it seems to me as if the Promised Land bit came and went – ending with the exile, despite the return – and the New Testament goes *sharp intake of breath * metaphorical – and the Promised Land is not really to do with the physical place that the Israelites were promised, but is to do with whoever catches hold of the spirit of the Law, in the way that Jesus describes and actually lives it. Then, they are living in a “promised land”, which perhaps (?) I don’t know – is that what is referred to as “The Kingdom of God”, which is when you live wherever you are, in whatever actual political landscape you do, with God as your King – obeying him within the spirit of the Law as expounded in the Sermon on the Mount?

So, does anyone know – is The Kingdom of God the metaphorical equivalent of The Promised Land?


Single Post Navigation

4 thoughts on “Back on familiar territory, but is it the Promised Land? #E100

  1. Laurie Nichols on said:

    Perhaps John the Baptist was preaching to not rest on their laurels and to never take their relationship for granted with God. Maybe he was saying that with the amount of water under the bridge Abraham;s covenant wasn’t enough. Just thinking out loud. 🙂

    • Thanks for your thought 🙂
      I think your idea about relationship is helpful – they assumed the relationship with God was fine – but maybe it is like what it is like with a “rights vs responsibility” balance. They have the promises, but they need to pull their weight somehow.
      It’s quite a leap from Judaism into Christianity in some ways – but I think it helps to see Christianity with a Jewish backdrop to get it to make sense.

  2. theotheri on said:

    I think science has unwittingly done metaphor a great disservice and managed to convince a great number of people that “metaphor” is inferior to “fact.” I think it is just the opposite – metaphor requires a higher form of thought and greater maturity to understand.

    And so to understand the Promised Land or Kingdom of Heaven as metaphors opens up, I think, a much deeper, richer reality than thinking of it as a concrete place.

    I wholeheartedly agree, by the way, with your comment above – that it helps to understand both the Old and the New Testament to keep in mind how they grew out of a Jewish culture.

    • I think it was concrete thinking that got the Pharisees all het up. I don’t think they seem very big on metaphor. Certainly Nicodemus had trouble with it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: